Entertainment For Lively Minds
Talking real life Monkey Tennis, sacred harp music and how *you* can be on our 100th podcast
Posted by David Hepworth on 20 May 2009 - 5:20pm.
This week we're joined by our TV bod Barry McIlheney and Aris Roussinos, who wrote the terrific article in the current issue about what's wrong with British TV, to talk about how TV programmes get commissioned. Plus: why albums are so-called, the eternal legacy of Officer Dibble (left), Fraser's weekend of sacred harp singing and how *you*can be on our 100th podcast. To leave a message call 07092 050466.
You can subscribe to the weekly Word podcast here or stream the latest one below.







Archie
I nominate Archie Valparaiso as the 'guest reader' who appears on the 100th podcast. Any seconders?
Any chance of Lawrence Miles being in a Word Podcast?
I thought his article on the filmlook was one of the best I've read in a long time.
Seconded
and he should be flown in first class and put up at the Dorchester
Accommodation For Prize Winner
If you can't afford the Dorchester, there's a cheap hostel in Piccadilly which I stayed at a few years back. It's a charming place; they let you collect and make your own bed, wires hang out of plug sockets, the communual toilets have a distinct reek of their own, strange stains congregate on faded yellow curtain showers and there's also the chance the place will be evacuated for a fire alarm at 3.30am in the morning. Reminds me of one of the "Spikes" in Orwell's "Down And Out In London And Paris".
ooh aah
did u just say that cantona coughs "arsenal" in the new ken loach?
Armando Iannuci revealed at
a recent BFI talk that there have been 3 serious approaches to him and broadcasters to actually make 'Monkey Tennis'. Until it was made clear that it was just monkeys. Playing tennis. So the idea and desperate programme makers went away
Best story he told was while they were writing the Armistice series in the empty 'Last Of the Summer Wine' offices and observing the episode plans on the wall that went 'Compo says 'You'll never get me on that contraption'. Next scene 'Compo flying down hill on contraption. One of the writers swapped one of the cards with 'Compo bursts puppy with cock'.
Hilarity ensued. We also got to a see a 2 minute clip of the US pilot of 'The Thick Of It' (probably illegally) which was ass clenchingly bad. As the lights went up, someone just let out incredulously 'What??'.
Depressing discussion
About how TV gets made nowadays. In fairness to the middle-aged comics fronting documentaries, the ones discussed (Fry, Merton, Wood) don't rely on scriptwriters in their "day jobs".
But the whole idea that having a snappy title and a celebrity in tow determines whether or not a programme gets commissioned is deeply depressing. No wonder I find I have fewer and fewer nights slumped in front of the TV and tend to be quite selective about what I watch. I guess from my point of view that's probably a good thing (and gives me more time among all the clever people here) but what effect is having on people not in the Word massive?
Podcast 100
I think the 100th podcast should be a birthday special featuring everyone who's ever been on it. Hepworth and Ellen obviously, but let's round up Harrison, Collins, Fitzpatrick, McIlheney, Forde, Jude R, Kate M, the whole bleeding lot of them. Fraser on the dials. Producer Matt back fiddling around with the level just one more time. Big old cake. Two minutes from each of them on their all-time favourite HORA. Sound Of Young Islington in the background. Sob. Gawd bless you ma'am. Etc.
A HORA is needed for number 100
Thanks for another
Thanks for another illuminating podcast. With, once more, regarding the vile state of television, if people didn't watch it then producers wouldn't be encouraged to make more. Mark Kermode has started a campaign to boycott crap films (Hottie & Nottie being an example) and maybe one of you could step forward to figurehead a similar campaign. The campaign for real television in a campaign for real ale style. Maybe you too could be invited to speak at a commons select committee as campaign for real ale were. Mwah hah.
I find television very educating. Every time somebody turns on the set, I go into the other room and read a book.
Groucho Marx
Illuminating is definitely the word
The guest on the 'cast (apologies, can't remember his name off-hand) asserted that maybe the credit crunch will be good for television i.e. people will have to put more effort into ideas because fewer will be commissioned.
Surely the opposite is true? Without wishing to be all hoighty-toighty from my high horse here, I would've thought TV execs will go for "lowest common denominator programs" like X-Factor, Britain's Got Talent and their ilk. These are big ratings successes and appeal to the broadest market. These programs don't have to axiomatically be of poor quality but sadly, it seems the case that they are more often than not.
I still don't believe there was ever a program called Fuck Off, I'm a Hairy Woman though...
There was you know. I saw ten minutes of it.
Hosted by comedian and New Statesman columnist Shazia Mirza.
It was awful.
shouldn't that be an hairy woman anyway ?
sorry, I can't get the old Alan Bennett sermon out of my head ...
On the subject of F*** off...
The exec producer, whom I know, of all the F*** off documentaries is currently experiencing a spell of job-free navel-gazing at the moment. Then again, so am I. And I'm about as far removed from the media circus as anyone.
On another subject, I'm from Manchester and use the term Dibble almost exclusively for the police, and so do most of my mates up there. Now I live in Sarf London and nobody knows what I'm talking about.
Didn't Dibble take to moonlighting as a fireman in later years
In these days where no public servant is above suspicion, I think we need to be told ...
[also somewhat delighted by this, from www.dibble.com: ""After researching most of the church records, wills and other written documents available we have not found the missing link to who might be the "original Dibble". The internet and email has helped all genealogy researchers worldwide combine their efforts only to find the same dead end - incomplete and missing records. Genealogy research has proven that there were many Dibble families in southwest England. One can only guess that the surname Dibble had been used there for quite some time and that we were much more likely to have descended from Saxons than from French immigrants. So even though we have not identified the original Dibble, where he was born, married or died, we do know that if we search far enough back in time we will find that we are all related. "]
I Think The Point . . .
. . . that Aris was making re the credit crunch was more to do with the new-look broadcasting landscape likely to emerge from this recession rather than with the quality of the programmes themselves. In other words, a publicly-funded Channel 4 would be more able to get back to its original remit, thus encouraging the BBC to do the same, while new owners or extinction for ITV and Five might also spell the beginning of the end for the race to make the next Fuck Off I'm Fat. Or something like that.
Spam (as in email)
Another common term derived from an old comedy. An IT colleague at work was genuinely surprised to find when I explained that its use for junk email came from an old Monty Python sketch where you got spam with everything. He's about the same age at the sketch, which might explain why he'd never heard of it.
There is a lot of crap television made
because lots of people are willing to watch it. (See also films, books, music, etc.) Having had a house mate who would lie on the couch for a few hours each evening and watch *anything*, I'm not surprised to see the utter shite on the TV listings each week. I've always assumed it runs along the same lines as soothing angry beasts by waving shiny objects at them.
Cast for 100th podcast: Hepworth, Ellen, Archie Valparaiso and Backwards7? Quality entertainment and an obvious Massive crowdpleaser.
100th podcast...
is it the right time for the return of the HORA?
A HORA worthy of the 100th pocast is a msut do
Ideally linked to the "special guest" who is only available on Wednesday
Bad TV
Excellent, though thoroughly depressing, talk about the state of British TV today. It is a shame that some producers don't get together and try to stop the rot, instead of pandering to the lowest common denominator - try to make some interesting and intelligent programmes. I mean the constant stream of Chav friendly television is depressing in the extreme...Cops On Camera, Chavs on Camera, Police Chase, Ambulance Chase, constant reality TV and Z-List celebs etc etc (jesus, I'll be subscribing to the Daily Mail soon...)
Aris offered a very interesting, albeit cynical, insight into the way TV programmes are pitched but I was wondering if he had any answers as to how it can improve. It was all a bit bleak.
This might be a silly question, but just how can American TV produce such a huge amount of excellent high quality dramas and comedies and we can't?
Over to you, bright young things
Found Aris fascinating, hadn't previously realised that James Lance's characters in both Absolute Power
and Moving Wallpaper were drawn quite so much from life ...
I wonder.....
Do they, the americans, produce a huge amount of good TV? Surely we are exposed to but a fraction of their output, as are they to ours. I have a friend in the U.S. who raves about all the british TV he ever sees, on public channels probably, and assumes all we have is of the same quality, as compared to what he sees as his homegrown crap. Whenever I have been in the U.S. I have struggled as hard as I do here to find something watchable. The more channels available, the less good there is to see.
Grass is always greener...
yes, I see your point.
However, I'm struggling to think of any recent British programmes that the Americans would want.
I know The Office and Little Britain were popular but in terms of TV drama - I can only think of Life On Mars that was original and of a good enough standard to compare with Deadwood, 24, West Wing, Sopranos, Flight Of The Conchords, Dexter, Californication etc.
I remember when Roger Waters singing
"I've got 13 channels of shit on the TV to choose from" was a reference to having too much choice.
These days, it would just mean the Sky subscription had lapsed and he was watching Freeview.
He could multiply that by 20
and call it Sky.
The point about rubbish American TV is a valid one and it can be adapted to any decade you want.
I'm sure that we could have a fun packed massive game naming crap Seventies sit-coms.
Merely musing but
It'll be the rank and file of Coast, anything by Attenborough and most nature docs, most of the bodice ripping 3 part dramas and anything adapted by Andrew Davies. These days most are co-productions with U.S., Canada or the european countries anyway.
What an honour
to be read out on the 'cast. (Since you ask, it's RAN-dell). However, when my comment about La Mossman was broadcast I had the distinct feeling of being hauled up before the whole school by Head Beak Hepworth. As n. molesworth would sa "You hav caught me, Sir, like a treen in a disabled spaceship" (thanks wikipedia - can't believe I don't have my own copy to hand, chiz chiz)
I know it's a small point
And Mr Hepworth did apologise, but he credited my remarks about the Eurovision and reading the blog before your homepage to Stimpy. MY ONE MOMENT IN THE BLEEDIN' SUN...
Chiz chiz, indeed
There was I
logging in on a Saturday night to listen to the podcast only to hear my name read out in relation to logging in on Saturday night.
What are the chances?
And I'm here too
What are the odds on that?
Ahh
now i can stop wondering what you are up to right now.
where's Mark?
Right here
In his pyjamas. Smoking a pipe.
You know I now have this image in my head
That's precisely it...
....except he wears wincyette.
Who's got the short fat hairy legs though?
Can we look forward to a Des O'Connor retrospective?
Would it be right to say at this point that on his current tour that Bob Dylan is playing all the rights notes, but not necessarily in the right order?
Hello Bongo!
Ernie - It's cold out tonight
Eric - Yeah I think I'll leave mine out as well
Can he say that on the BBC?
Ernie: Can you telephone from an aeroplane?
Eric: Everyone can tell a phone from an aeroplane! This boys a fool...
He'll never
sell any ice cream going at that speed.....
(yeah it is from the BBC shows but can't find it on youtube so here's another one)
- 'You not going to read that book are you?
- 'No I'm just going to look at the words, you fool'
stopped watching telly
when wee bairn was born. Have turned box on once since Jan 19th. Have watched Red Riding on torrent and bought a few things - Red Riding again, The Long Firm and Whitechapel on DVD. Watched part of one episode of Later... on the iPlayer. Lined up Inbetweeners but got distracted. Used to have loads of How Clean is Your Arse type nonsense on. Don't miss it at all.
Another view on the C4/BBC/ITV story
is from two guys who also have a bit of experience on TV between them:
http://www.clivejames.com/video/library/3
[go to Isaacs interview, nifty interface imo]
When they get round to the current state of TV their explanation is v simple. As soon as ITV bids no longer required a quality component they no longer contained them ... and then the BBC followed ITV down, et voila ...
Sacred Harp Music...
...typed into Google: this thread comes up sixth.
"Sacred Harp" in a Spotify search throws up an item that would probably not please the religious minded.
In defence of TV
I find that even with the limited number of channels in my house there's always something I'm happy to watch for the 45 minutes a day that I spend in front of the TV. I don't think the average evening's TV is worse now than it was in 1982. It's a good deal better. But there's a lot of junk because there are a lot of channels and they have to be filled with something. Much of that will be a pale imitation of something that did well on one of the other channels. What amuses me about TV, and I think this was reflected in this podcast, is that it's full of clever people pretending to be stupid.
The major disappointment about TV in the last ten years is that the vision of a multi-channel future involved lots of specialist services all financed by advertising aimed at specialist audiences. It hasn't happened. The advertisers tend to want big audiences and that means lowest common denominator programming, an expression which I'm not using pejoratively at all. Less people are going to watch a documentary about Miles Davis than a talent show featuring Susan Boyle. That's just common sense. Actually, *I'd* rather watch the latter than the former. Because that's the thing. *Approving* of a programme is one thing. Watching it is another one entirely.
You're showing me that hook Mr. H
- Less people are going to watch a documentary about Miles Davis than a talent show featuring Susan Boyle. That's just common sense. Actually, *I'd* rather watch the latter than the former. -
but I'm not biting this time!
Anyway, thanks for the podcast.....fascinating insight on todays TV.
.......and since no one else has mentioned it, that's the best quality sound(to my ears)of any podcast so far. I imagine that Frazer has got it all right this time rather than y'all being in a room without air conditioning.
*ahem*
"less people" or "fewer people" ?
Media's Perfect Storm
All media faces a perfect storm of technolgical change, economic downturn, fragmengting and/or declining audiences.
Most media is advertiser funded. Which leads to the other great conundrum facing British based media companies - the BBC. Whether the BBC does a good job or bad job is not the issue - what matters is the deep skew it puts on the competitive landscape.
When we say "advertisers" we mean companies and institutions that many if not most of us work for. The biggest "advertiser" of all - being (the) government in all its various guises.
Advertisers want to reach the largest number of relevant people - whether its mass-market perdominatly female audiences for household products or upmarket males for beer.
Many of the kinds of programmes referred to in the Podcast have in television terms - miniscule audiences. Therefore, it is not in the interests of advertisers to have "lowest common denominator" programmes as these will not enhance a brand or necessarily shift a product.
In reality, there is at least as much "good" stuff as there is "bad" and to argue there is not more "choice" is disingenuous. Choice is a loaded term - so it may be better to say that there are a far greater number of viewing options.
It is not advertisers, or cynical programme makers or avaricous media companies that are to blame - it is ourselves and the way our lives changing that is affecting TV and all media. We simply do not use print or broadcast media in the same way anymore.
The media landscape is changing inexorably and the web will be the dominant platform in the not too distant future. I am writing this on a laptop from a beach in Cornwall. If I didn't have to make sandcastles - I might choose to watch "James Brown saves Boston" on I-Player next.
If you do not want to watch "Suicide Bummers" - you can watch "Classic Albums: Aja" or a rarely seen Preston Sturges movie.
You can now - you couldn't before. And that's good isn't it?
Assuming there's enough of that disgraceful advertising cash to make it possible
Classic Suicide Bummer Albums...
in production as I type.
"I don't think the average
"I don't think the average evening's TV is worse now than it was in 1982. It's a good deal better."
I have to disagree with that I'm afraid, but I will cite evidence to back me up. Here's a sample selection of what was on offer in one week in 1982. Topped and tailed by, well, you.
Saturday 6 November 1982
Old Grey Whistle Test (BBC2)
Another chance to see the previous night's edition - with Mark Ellen and David Hepworth
An Evening with Max Wall (C4)
Saturday Superstore (BBC1)
Guests included Squeeze and Barry Took
The Best of Saturday Night Live (ITV)
The Epic That Never Was (BBC2)
Documentary on the unmade 1937 version of I, Claudius featuring unseen rushes footage
Objects of Affection (BBC2)
Alan Bennett previews his new season of TV work
Carrott's Lib (BBC1)
Series 1, Show 6
The Life and Adventures of Nicholas Nickleby (C4)
The first part of the new David Edgar adaptation
Walter's Weekly (Radio 1)
John Walters interviewed William Burroughs.
Sunday 7 November 1982
Act 3 of Wagner's Ring Cycle (BBC2)
(Preceded by a documentary)
Omnibus: 'Brits on Broadway'(BBC1)
Featuring interviews with Richard Burton and David Hare
The Boys from the Blackstuff (BBC2)
The final episode thereof
David Jessel in conversation with Lord Denning (BBC2)
The Professionals (ITV)
The episode 'Foxhole on the Roof'
Sit Up and Listen (ITV)
Michael Hordern reads some Tennyson
Monday 8 November 1982
The Further Adventures of Lucky Jim (BBC2)
by Clement and La Frenais
Whatever You Want (C4)
Politics / music / comedy show with Keith Allen
Going Out (C4)
New Phil Redmond drama
The Eleventh Hour (C4)
First edition of a new slot for independent films
Tuesday 9 November 1982
The Young Ones (BBC2)
'Demolition'
Play for Today (BBC1)
'Intensive Care' by Alan Bennett
Arena (BBC2)
A profile on Joe Orton
Wednesday 10 November 1982
Profile of Gabriel Garcia Marquez (BBC2)
Profile of Parisian singer Marie-Paul Belle (BBC2)
QED (BBC1)
The Riddle of Sleep
The Barchester Chronicles (BBC2)
Visions (C4)
A series on cinema featuring an interview with Paul Schrader
The Morecambe and Wise Show (ITV)
Thursday 11 November 1982
Yes Minister (BBC2)
'Equal Opportunities' - the first episode of Series 3, with Eleanor Bron
Only Fools and Horses (BBC1)
'No Greater Love…'
Shelley (ITV)
'Brave New World'
City Lovers (C4)
A play by Nadine Gordimer
FILM: Sitting Ducks (C4)
Part of a World Cinema strand
Friday 12 November 1982
The Tube (C4)
Second ever edition
Pleasure Palaces (C4)
A documentary about cinema usherettes
Did You See…? (BBC2)
Discusses the Alan Bennett season
Our Winnie (BBC2)
By Alan Bennett
The Old Grey Whistle Test (BBC2)
A new edition.
assumption of low expectation
Well,as far as the "good stuff" is concerned we have got to thank our *Stars* everyday for the BBC.
I get the feeling that the license fee IS safe,regardless of Government "hue",if purely due to the fact that there is simply not enough advertising money to go round at the moment,let alone for another outlet.
My only clear conclusion: Armando Ianucci is a VISIONARY!
Stephen Fry and House on 'more choice'
in broadcasting at the turn of the 90's
didn't do him out of a job thou
Endurance
Stephen Fry probably needs to take a break from TV and perhaps even this blog, but here he is at his best, delivering a heartfelt speech on the future role of public service broadcasting last year. Will Hutton and David Attenborough also give speeches at the same site:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/thefuture/video_fry.shtml
Clive James was always banging on about the dangers of deregulation on his TV shows in the 80's, and I still ponder his warnings today as I sit watching "Most Extreme Caught Under the Influence 3", or even "Total Wipeout" - a pretty direct translation of the sort of Japanese programmes James used to show.
Here's a transcript of a lecture he gave to the BBC board of governors in 1991:
http://www.clivejames.com/lectures/preaching
Just caught up with the james essay
Superb, thanks so much for posting the link
Glad to be of service, Nick
Clive James is always worth a read, I reckon, on any subject.
Re. the depressing state of TV...
For my money, Neil Simon just about nailed the reasons why in his semi-autobiographical play 'Laughter on the 23rd Floor'. The action is set in the writers' office on 'The Max Prince Show' a fictitious 1950s American TV comedy - the kind Simon himself once wrote for.
At one point Max (who is closely modeled on Sid Caesar) claims that he has received a letter from the brass at NBC telling him to "Give the people shit". One of the writers asks why. Max replies: "Because they can make money on shit. A potful. Drive up to Connecticut, they got big shit Tudor houses wherever you look. That's why they invented television. They put shit on for people to watch. They advertise shit. The people run out and buy the shit. Their kids break the shit, so they buy them more shit. Then the shit moguls go to France for the summer while the poor people stay here and watch more shit. That's why I got a letter saying 'Give the people shit'".
ITV etc. in a nutshell, I'd say.