Entertainment For Lively Minds
In how many ways is this advert just *wrong*?

I'm not one of those people who thinks that all advertisers are stupid. Generally they're clever, often a bit too clever. Nonetheless I fail to see how they could have approved this latest ad for Louis Vuitton bags with a straight face. As Don Draper would have been the first to point out, what kind of fools do they take us for?
Are we expected to believe that Bono and his wife have just flown themselves into this remote part of the bush? And that they are so expert at flying that they didn't need a landing strip? What are they doing there? Saving lives or something? Is Ms Hewson wise to pole up to meet the village elders with a neckline that low? Won't they wonder why Bono's bought his bloody guitar? And why he's got a few things for overnight in that frankly chavvy-looking bag. Bet the first tribesman he meets is wearing a pirated U2 tee shirt and carrying a market-bought knock-off of the bag.
- More from David Hepworth.
- Login or register to post comments










Give them credit for one thing
I hate the advert but I'm so far away from their target customer that it's probably a ringing endorsement for the strategy.
You're reading it wrong
They've just returned from holiday and are walking through their garden, past one of their children's toys.
If we didn't hate Bono and all he stands for so much
would it still be so stupid?
Probably.
That luggage is as vulgar as it comes. It screams conspicuous consumption and is beloved of the nouveau riche. Like Bono.
It's also beloved of the slightly less nouveau riche.
I believe this advert was as a result of Keef's guitar roadie..
They bought him a nice posh Louis Vuitton guitar case because he kept complaining about the horrible old, battered, smelly, leathery object with funny things stuck on that he had to hump round from gig to gig.
Then the horrible old, battered, smelly, leathery object with funny things stuck on complained so they bought him one as well. And put him in an advert.
yes
you are expected to believe! and you will..it's Bono and he's Goddo!
Hopefully
they've had to make an emergency landing and are stranded in the bush, oh, and the radio's gone down too. Trouble is, Sting and Trudie will probably be passing and rescue them...
Bit Petty David
This is my first post after a few weeks of lurking.
The advert does not seem have the context that you imply.
See the Link.
http://www.luxist.com/2010/08/30/bono-and-ali-hewson-are-latest-vuitton-...
Not that I'm their greatest fan, but I hope that the post is not just another U2 shit kicking excuse from The Word.
That's all.
Welcome aboard
I thought you might have a point, so I swapped Bono and Ali Hewson for two of my favourite artists, Glen Campbell and Bjork.
But even this - in my mind, at least - can't undo the inherent stupidity of the picture.
Thanks Fraser
Picture may be inherently stupid but the sentiment seems to be good. The products seem to be for a greater good and I just thought that David's post was a little below the belt and as I said petty when I read where this was all coming from.
If an advertiser comes along and says....
...'here's some money - whether it's for you or your charity - and in return we'd like you to pose with one or our products in a field by a plane", you would have to be heroically naive not to think that you might get a bit of stick for it.
A thought
Fraser managed to photoshop Glen Campbell and Bjork onto that picture pretty fast. It got me thinking: did Bonio and Bonette actually go to the location in person? If so (and I have no idea), would it not have been easier to photoshop their heads onto a stock photo? It would certainly be better for the planet. Carbon footprint vs. Airmiles. Which is best depends who is looking.
Fair Point David
but I do see DoubleDips point of view...and I haven't been active on the blog for over a year but I do detect at fairly anti U2 bias from Word Towers in the last couple of years.
Do I take it they spend too much time over at Q and Mojo for your liking?
I apologise if I'm mistaken.
U2
Some people (including the editor) love 'em, some don't. There's no policy in place.
Personally I don't like the band, but think that Bono is very much a force for good, whatever his faults or motives. I'm glad he's there doing what he does.
But this is still a lousy advert, IMHO.
To be fair,
Bono has never made any, er, bones, about the fact that he is (or rather was) aspirational and enjoys his lifestyle, and good luck to him. If he was someone like Trudie Styler who bangs on about climate change all the time it would have been intensely annoying and hypocritical. As it is, his most notable campaigns are about alleviating poverty and AIDS, which is not really in conflict with an image like this, daft as it may be. Like me, I think he (and Geldof for that matter) generally favour raising the living standards of the developing world rather than the uber-fashionable view that their way of life represents some kind of purer, nobler existence to which we decadent westerners should return. I like to think he might find much of merit in Matt Ridley's excellent The Rational Optimist.
Gah! I was about to Photoshop the plane's registration number
to read T-WAT. Doesn't seem worth it now :-)
struggling
to work out what other context the advert has but to sell luxury bags to rich people. Bonio and his chums think they can get away with campaigns like this without affecting their (long gone) cred, justifying it with some (small) charity link. It doesn't wash. Shit-kicking U2 articles won't stop until there's no shit left to kick.
Have to agree with you
I believe it is Mrs Hewsons company, started with great intentions, didn't do so well, got bailed out and hence the 'Louis' advert. OK maybe not aimed at our demographic but the heart seems to be in the right place.
Welcome to The Word Website
I hope you are not an Oasis fan. Any sh*t-kicking that U2 get is nothing compared to the abuse the Gallagher Bros' band get.
And if anyone asks if you like Snow Patrol, just say no. A lot easier.
I can attest to that
Being Oasis and Proud is hard work here.
But they're all wrong so it doesn't bother me
Don't worry...
as long as I'm here with my Jamiroquai and Level 42 cds you'll be left alone!
Steady on, DoubleDip
It's only Bono.
I don't wish him or his U2 pals any malice: they're just a bit...er...anti-rock? And not in a punk way.
If I ever thought Word were gonna waste print on a U2 feature then, Private-Eye-esque, I'd have to take out a prescription. Just to cancel it.
Mind you, I think there has been one, hasn't there?
And don't even start
on the crass phallic imagery.
Sometimes these things are just wrong in every way imaginable. You saw this one over the summer, I presume?
Brilliant!
Are Viz still doing Up The Arse corner?!
Dunno
But I've been looking for an excuse to say that this would qualify.
ha ha ha ha
And this
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2055/2482026967_5ddfe85e73.jpg
Edun
A brand created to boost manufacture in and encourage trade with Africa, with only 15% of it's range made there.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870435890457547831050459387...
It's so wrong, it's right.
It's so wrong, it's right.
The whole campaign is a Gstaad ski slope of iIl-judgement
If Gorbachev in the back of a smoky cab - gazing nostalgically at the remains of the Berlin Wall, as you do - was rather strange, then Pele and Maradona, playing table football in a smoky Madrid café (with Zidane roped in as the ref, his bag having been embossed "ZZ" in gold in case anyone thought it was Howard Webb), was none-more-"huh?"
But, as we know, Annie Leibovitz does need the money.
Bono on safari
They're carpet baggers, was my instant reaction. With their own carpet bag.
A conspiracy of air traffic controllers
Bono: "Wait a minute, this isn't Cannes..."
Mrs Bono: "Do you hear lions?"
Why
doesn't Mr Bono just stick to making music with the popular beat combo U2 and save himself a lot of silly bother?
He's going...
...to do his back in carrying his bag like that.
If the picture was supposed to be realistic..
There'd be another plane in the distance coming into land carrying Bonio's hat.
Who's that girl?
I suppose that full proof that I'm not in the target demographic is the fact that I would have had no idea who the woman was and just assumed she was a hollywood actress whose films I hadn't seen. I only read the thread because I assumed it would be a good forum for unjustified but amusing Bongo baiting.
It's
Mrs Bono.
Is she
Pro Bono here?
African Child
Reminds me of the Russell Brand character's pop video in the opening scenes of the film "Get Him To The Greek."
Dreadful movie.
And is that..
a Masai's purloined loincloth draped over Bono's shoulder, or are they perhaps Masonic entrails?
The more you look at this picture the more it keeps on giving.
Mrs Bono's body appears to have been badly photoshopped.
Can't quite work out what, but the proportions look all wrong.
Here's another shot from the same shoot.
I think you're right. Something odd certainly seems to be afoot. (Or awaist.)
looking at this
it looks as if the original ad will end up on photoshop disasters pretty soon
i mean for frigs sakes...
they get Annie Liebowitz to take the feckin' photo and then they Photoshop it...Surely to Jesus it would have been cheaper for them to get Bongo and the missus to stand in front of a blue screen, hire me to take the photos on my 'take-to-the-pub' pocket camera and email the shots to the ad agency who'll do the real legwork anyway?
Yes, everything looks fairly normal here.
Well, she does.
Afoot, a-waist and, indeed, a-face.
Mrs Bono could well change her name to Botox.
"Smile!" saye Annie L..
"Oi am feckin' smoilin', fer feck's sake.."
In Fairness
Mrs. Bono passes through my place of work every now and again, she's a very attractive woman.
Hurrah! Not just me who
Hurrah! Not just me who spotted the Barbie proportions.
Still, all in all, it could be worse. He could be sporting a copy of Word.
Helen
I HAVE submitted the original advert here to Photoshop disasters precisely on account of the massive head/no waist rule....oh and the fact that Mr and Mrs Bonio's legs don't appear to be interacting with the grass around them.....oh and they look 2-D. Owweer, are they ghosts??
Carrying a guitar?
He has precious little use for it normally. Perhaps he's off to donate it to an orphan.
Orphan-box
They'll be taking one back for Madonna.
Pilot's license
Do either of them have one?
The number of the plane
It's different in the two pictures.
Don't think so Miles
It's ZS-MR, give or take an extra letter or two after the R.
In the first picture you can only see the ZS and in the second you can see S-MR.
(I can't believe I just spent two minutes of my life working that out...)
OK
So it's a South African plane. Pretty sure that's not the most impoverished part of Africa (though not without it's own problems).
Why does
Louis Vuitton luggage have 'Luncheon Vouchers' written all over it?
Horrible, vulgar stuff.
Bono's a
"George Osbourne" in my books but dear ol' Keef also posed for this awful brand. Any naysayers on that front?
I bet
his face was better quality leather than the luggage.
Not me
The ad isn't nearly as silly.
Here is the making of Video
Love the round applause at the end. Well done you managed to walk 10 yards without tripping up : )
The Buzz
in view of my (recovering) spacehead status, I quite liked this one:
and its print partner, in spite of myself
He blessed the rains
“Hurry boy it’s waiting there for you...”
Bono’s hand paused in mid pen-stroke. The nib of his Mont Blanc dawdled over a half-finished poem he had commissioned himself to write for an upcoming issue of Q magazine that he was guest editing. He gazed out of the window of the light aircraft at a herd of Zebra as they thundered across the parched savannah, stirring low clouds of red dust.
The small plane was not properly airborne. A team of men and women dressed in the traditional business attire of the PR caste bore the fuselage on their shoulders, filing across the Serengeti in two columns, at a walking pace. When they reached their destination they knelt in unison. The moment the aircraft touched down, two of the group broke away and began to hastily anoint the tyres of the landing gear with African soil. The remaining lackeys formed themselves into a human staircase by the door.
Bono and his wife stepped out into the African heat and began a leisurely descent of the PR pyramid. When they reached the bottom they both dropped to their knees and reverentially kissed the ground.
As a gesture of solidarity with the starving African continent, the couple had dressed themselves in tight-fitting corsets designed to dramatically reduce their waist size. Bono’s hand luggage had been woven from locally-sourced materials by a species of African condor hunted to near extinction by white supremacist groups during the apartheid era. The fabric was decorated with abstract designs that Nelson Mandela had doodled on some Hilton Hotels notepaper during an hour long telephone conversation with the UN goodwill ambassador - Geri Halliwell.
The arrival of Mr and Mrs Hewson had not gone unnoticed. A pride of lions shading themselves, in the name of love, under a nearby baobab tree watched them closely. An old male with a receding mane, plugged with russet implants, rose up on his haunches and padded over to them.
“Aslan!”
The hackneyed Christian anachronism and the politically disgraced lion embraced each other warmly.
“Great album, sorry I couldn’t make it to the rooftop performance.”
“I was going to call it: No Lion On The Horizon.”
“Heh.”
“About the whole political exile thing...”
“Ah, you know, shit happens.”
Privately Aslan was still smarting from his landslide defeat in the Narnian elections that had seen him declared a war criminal by the incoming fawn government and unceremoniously bundled into the nearest wardrobe. In the UK the weather was cold and he had been forced to live in reduced circumstances as male nanny to a group annoyingly perky children who had been sent to live with their uncle by their exasperated parents.
“Did anything come of that whole child mauling incident?”
“Diplomatic immunity is a wonderful thing my friend.”
“So what are you doing in Africa?”
“Backpacking... You know just getting my head together... Reconnecting with my lion roots...”
A joy.
One of your finest, b7. I fairly pissed myself at the "human staircase".
Hope springs eternal
(I'd save Ali obviously)
Bono Vuitton
This is beyond parody. Get a grip Bono
I think it's high time...
...that "Michael Bublé Being Stalked By A Velociraptor" was replaced with "Bono Being Stalked By A Lion".
Ahem
see crappy photoshop above
Yeah sorry...
... I meant in the sense of lots of people piling onto your excellent work with examples of their own, using the same lion picture, as with Mikey Bubbles.
of course
I could have clicked your link and found out what you meant so the apology is mine sir
Dodo to Bono
"I see you're still going out with the same old bag."
'Yes, you too?'
Isn't it just an ad at the end of the day -
And ads are meant to be aspirational. Whatever we may think of them, to the kind of audience that either can afford Vuitton luggage or aspire to buying it, Bono and his wife represent perfect role models.
I don't think it's designed to be a realistic picture of a plane landing in Africa but just a bunch of images that conjure up glamour and romance and something slightly unreal. So in answer to the original question I don't think it's "wrong" in any way particularly - may even be quite right in a lot of ways.
I've read
about the charitable gestures that underpin this advert but it still doesn't stop me from thinking the ad itself is a laughable crock of shit on so many levels. In fact I'm fed up with shite final products in the advertising world being defended by virtue of charitable gestures on the part of the stakeholders involved. Crap is crap whatever the motive but it actually becomes more worthy of piss-taking because the PR machine tries to head off ANY criticism by trying to declare negative comments a no go area simply because Bono Tarzan and Jane have not taken their cut in the ad's budget and have instead given it to charidee instead. I mean it's really important we know that because if we didn't have that sobering thought in our minds we'd all have died laughing wouldn't we at the live action "reimagining" of Madagascar courtesy of this photo?
I can live with commerce and charity blurring the lines because I can see the that ultimately charity gains simply because money from hollow souls - who can't define themselves unless they wear a label bought by Keef or Bono or would die of embarrassment unless they were seen to have paid top whack for a Vuitton bag in which to put their soiled pants and smelly socks after a few night's stay in a hotel on Park Lane - is as valuable as money from chaps like me who mock and jeer from the sidelines. They give more and more people benefit. Hurrah! But I'll be damned if I can't continue to think these things through rather than just lap up the spin that accompanies such advertising ventures these days.
But let's not kid ourselves. Those same hollow souls massaging their egos by associating their purchases with images of smiley happy black children in Africa will also marvel at what Mrs. Bono is wearing, imagining themselves and their Hedge Fund managing husbands in Bono's attire. Lo and behold, as they luxuriate in the fug of doing something good in the world by associating their buys with some charitable cause they've been simultaneously lulled into a level of suppliance that means they extend the PR-driven goodwill into making purchases from Bono's clothing range. And oh look, Vuitton, who has a 49% stake in the Bono's Edun clothing range, will also gain a bit more. So, hit them with charity and side-step them with the clothing range. Job done.
Oh, I'm sorry ETHICAL clothing range. For god's sake please don't anybody forget that the clothing range is ethical: we must keep guilt in the equation at all costs. Heaven forbid I might buy a pair of pants that aren't "ethical". I've looked at the Men's range on the Edun site and a jumper (sorry, an oversized twisted striped crew) is 225 Euros/£196. Wow, production costs have really gone through the roof in those "ethical" factories in Tanzania.
Lifestyle advertising makes me laugh whatever motivates it and this ad is no exception. Being right about what you do and the motivation behind doing it is not in itself a sufficient argument to deny the fact that a pop star looks like a bit of a cock nor the fact that Annie Liebowitz is slumming it and compromising her art, nor that the PR machine for the fashion industry is the last organisation to be claiming some moral high ground to justify making us feel guilty about what we buy and from whom given their track record in how they get their stuff made.
And no, I don't buy into the argument that gestures and actions like this make a difference in the long run because it "raises awareness" and it "sends out the right message". That's an overstated and simplified argument to a complex issue of which one factor is the question of the sustainability of the economic model into which the charity/ethical angle is positioned.
So, in summary. Picture + me = Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
I love your posts
They're always so...long
I do go on
don't I? Stream of consciousness stuff with nary a nod to self-editorialisation except for correcting chronic typos that make me look like a inexcusable muppet. Fear of sounding like I didn't mean it is probably another factor as is the fact that words are one of the few things I can show off a bit with
If I previewed I'd only mither and faff even more.
What's a wind-bag to do? Answers in less than 10 words please. :)
I enjoy them though, don't get me wrong
Keep them coming!
I love your posts!
And despite occasional appearances to the contrary I always agree with them.
I think the pursuit of solipsistic marketing and brand logic at the expense of usable quality products has led the whole of Western popular culture - and industry - deep up its own fundament. In other words - we've ALL jumped the shark and real oddities like this are an inevitable consequence. The controls have been handed to the greedy super rich and a bunch of wittering berks
Even if we weren't about to go utterly skint without remedial action we need to go back to some basic principles.
Aah_B's seen the light.
In less than ten words?
This is how we'll Word blog from now on. Just...
Better out than in
You enjoyed that didn't you? So did I.
It seems
he still hasn't found what he's looking for?
It'll be behind that plane
Mrs Bono must be about 4'9"
Not necessarily
Himself might be standing on a termite hill.
He'll be crowd surfing on insects next
Arms outstretched...